Re-key Vs. Replace Locks – How to Decide What's Best for You

Re-key Vs. Replace Locks – How to Decide What's Best for You

From moving into a new home and wanting added security to ensuring old employees can’t access filing cabinets, there are a number of instances that may require you to either rekey or replace your locks. Whatever your reason may be, it can sometimes be tricky to decide whether rekeying or replacing the lock is most beneficial. This guide will take you through how to make a practical decision.

What Does It Mean to Rekey A Lock? 

When rekeying a lock, you need to alter the lock mechanism to ensure the old key no longer opens it, and replacement keys are needed to do so. The rekeying process involves removing the pins and springs within the lock cylinder, and then replacing these with new pins and springs that work and fit with a new key.

Rekeying a lock is a popular option for people who simply want to maintain key control, usually after a house move or having lost a key, to ensure unwanted people can’t gain access. Key control refers to accounting for all the keys made to operate that specific lock - once keys are loaned out to friends, family members or colleagues, the key control is then lost.

The Benefits of Rekeying A Lock

Because locks are often lubricated during the process of rekeying them, they ultimately operate more smoothly and with greater ease as a result of this process.

If a completely new style of lock isn’t required, rekeying a lock is an affordable choice to make, as it is a quick method that doesn’t take the lock out of service for a prolonged length of time. Rekeying a lock is therefore particularly ideal for locks for domestic door keys, as the process is both fast and easy, while also providing an increased sense of security for your home. 

What Does It Mean to Replace A Lock?

There are many reasons as to why people may want to replace a lock, including wanting to update to a more modern lock such as an electronic one, or to replace the locks purely for aesthetics. But, if a lock is damaged and beyond the help of rekeying, replacement locks are the best option. 

With so many different types of lock available, those redecorating or making home improvements may choose to replace the lock with one that complements the design of the building. Another common reason for replacing locks is to accommodate the person using them. Lever handle locks, for example, are generally much easier to use than locks that include a knob handle, and are therefore a popular choice for those with disabilities or people suffering from pain in their hands. 

The Benefits of Replacing A Lock 

Finding the right lock with the right security is crucial in ensuring both your home and belongings are kept safe. One of the benefits of replacing a lock is to customise the lock to suit your preferences, from the ways in which the lock looks and feels to the levels of protection it provides. Replacing your locks also gives you the opportunity to upgrade the security they deliver, with the option to pick new and improved designs that are currently on the market, as opposed to just rekeying and having to stick with the lock you already have. 

Is It Cheaper to Rekey Or Replace Locks?

Generally speaking, rekeying a lock is a cheaper option compared to replacing it. This is due to the fact that replacing a lock involves paying out for an entirely new lock body, whereas rekeying means you’ll just have to pay for the new replacement pins and springs within the lock instead.

Overall, it’s best to look at all the options and all the kinds of lock available before making your decision, as well as assessing the reasons as to why the lock needs changing overall, to determine which benefits will be most advantageous to you. 

Leave a Comment